Cooking in the Keys

  • Recipe Index
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Contact
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipe Index
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Contact

subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Recipe Index
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Contact

×
Home » Recipes » Appetizers

Stone Crab Claws with Mustard Sauce

felice kaufman author bio
By Felice Kaufman · Updated: Nov 19, 2026
Jump to Recipe - Print Recipe

Stone crab claws with mustard sauce are a Florida Keys favorite, with sweet, tender meat that pairs perfectly with creamy mustard sauce. Here's how to choose, crack, and serve them, plus my easy homemade mustard sauce recipe. Since the claws are sold cooked, prep is minimal.

Stone crab claws on a plate with mustard sauce and lemons.

Quick Look: Stone Crab Claws with Mustard Sauce

  • Sweet, tender claws: Served chilled, with no cooking needed at home.
  • Creamy mustard sauce: Tangy Dijon, lemon, and horseradish complement the sweet crab meat.
  • Prep time: 5 minutes.
  • Servings: 4, using 3 pounds of claws.

SUMMARIZE AND SAVE THIS POST ON

ChatGPT
Google AI
Perplexity
Claude
Add As a Trusted Google Source
Jump to:
  • Quick Look: Stone Crab Claws with Mustard Sauce
  • Why I Love Them!
  • How to Crack Stone Crab Claws
  • Serving
  • Mustard Sauce for Stone Crab Claws
  • Where Can I Get Stone Crabs Online?
  • How Many Claws Per Person?
  • Are Stone Crab Claws Expensive?
  • What Size Should I Buy?
  • Storage
  • Where to Get Stone Crabs in Key West
  • More Seafood Recipes
  • Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce FAQ
  • Stone Crab Claws with Mustard Sauce Recipe

Why I Love Them!

Living in the Florida Keys, I look forward to stone crab season every October. The meat is sweet and tender, and the claws are sold already cooked, so it's an easy seafood dinner to put together at home.

Some of my friends set stone crab traps in the ocean here, so a few times each season, I'm lucky enough to get claws fresh off the boat.

The meat is sweet and tender, and the claws are cooked right away, so it's an easy seafood dinner to put together at home.

I like serving them cold with lemon wedges and my homemade mustard sauce.

Stone crabs with mustard sauce on a board.

How to Crack Stone Crab Claws

Crack the claws gently so you don't crush the sweet meat inside. Use a stone crab cracker, a mallet, nutcrackers, or the flat side of a sturdy chef's knife.

To use a knife, lay the flat side of the blade on the flat side of the claw and press down a few times, as if you're smashing a garlic clove.

A stone crab cracker, like the one shown above, makes it even easier. You can pick one up at most fish markets. Place the claw in the cracker and gently press down on each joint, then remove the loose shell pieces.

Don't have a cracker? Ask your fishmonger to crack the claws for you. I've used a hammer. That works too!

stone crab cracker with crabs.

You can also pick up a stone crab cracker at the fish market.

This lightweight aluminum device, as shown above, makes cracking crabs easier.

Place the claw in the device and gently press down on the joints. Remove the loosened shell pieces.

Serving

  • Ask the fishmonger to crack them if you don't have a cracker at home.
  • Crack gently and remove loose shell pieces before serving.
  • Keep the claws cold until you're ready to eat.
  • Make the mustard sauce first so it's ready when you crack the claws.
  • Choose freshness over size. I find medium claws just as flavorful as jumbo claws.

For a chilled seafood platter, serve the claws alongside Key West pink shrimp cocktail.

For dessert, our key lime pie is a must!

Mustard Sauce for Stone Crab Claws

This creamy, tangy mustard sauce is easy to make. Mix the ingredients in a medium-sized bowl, then season with salt to taste.

Serve the sauce cold alongside cracked stone crab claws.

The full measurements are in the recipe card below.

  • Mayonnaise
  • Dijon mustard
  • Worcestershire sauce
  • Lemon juice
  • Creamy horseradish
  • Salt

For a buttery dipping sauce, try my lemon garlic butter sauce.

key west stone crabs with mustard sauce and mallet.

Where Can I Get Stone Crabs Online?

You can order stone crab claws online from Key Largo Fisheries in the Florida Keys. Check the available sizes, shipping schedule, and delivery options before ordering.

If you're visiting the Keys, look for fresh claws at local seafood markets during Florida's stone crab harvest season, October 15 through May 1.

How Many Claws Per Person?

Plan on about ¾ pound of shell-on stone crab claws per person, matching the portions in this recipe. The number of claws will vary by size.

Serve the claws with lemon wedges and creamy sweet coleslaw for an easy seafood dinner.

See my guide to side dishes for a stone crab dinner for more ideas.

Are Stone Crab Claws Expensive?

Yes, stone crab claws are one of the pricier seafoods. They're harvested by hand, the season only runs from October 15 to May 1, and prices change with supply and demand, so they're often highest during busy holiday and tourist weeks. Larger claws cost more per pound than medium claws.

To save money, buy medium claws. They have the same sweet flavor as the big ones, just in smaller pieces. Call ahead or compare a couple of local fish markets, because prices can change from week to week.

stone crab claws with mustard sauce

What Size Should I Buy?

Stone crab claws are sold by size, commonly labeled medium, large, jumbo, and colossal. Larger claws cost more, but I find the sweet flavor similar across sizes. Choose the size that fits your budget.

Florida's minimum legal harvest size is 2⅞ inches, measured from the elbow joint to the tip of the lower, fixed finger of the claw. This measurement is different from the size grades used by seafood markets. Florida FWC

Storage

Store cooked stone crab claws in a leak-proof container in the coldest part of your refrigerator. For the best flavor, enjoy them within 24 hours, and use them within two days of purchase.

Have a couple of claws left? Pick out the meat and make my scrambled eggs with stone crab claws the next morning.

Where to Get Stone Crabs in Key West

Our favorite places for stone crab claws in Key West include A & B Lobster House, Blue Heaven, DJ's Clam Shack, and Eaton Street Seafood. Check with each restaurant before visiting, since menus and availability can change.

Look for claws with moist, sweet meat. Freshness matters more to me than claw size.

More Seafood Recipes

  • Peel and eat key west pink shrimp recipe
    Peel and Eat Shrimp Recipe
  • key west spiny lobster rolls on teal plate
    Key West Lobster Rolls
  • pan cooked snapper fillets with lemon and veggies
    Pan Seared Snapper Fillets
  • Three golden crab cakes with claw meat, remoulade sauce, and a lemon wedge.
    Panko Crab Cakes With Crab Claw Meat

Go to Florida Keys Seafood Recipes for more options.

Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce FAQ

What is mustard sauce for stone crab claws made of?

My mustard sauce is made with mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, Worcestershire sauce, lemon juice, creamy horseradish, and salt. Stir the ingredients together and serve cold alongside cracked stone crab claws.

Are stone crabs from the United States?

Yes, stone crabs live in the warm coastal waters of the southeastern United States, along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts from about North Carolina to Texas, and south into the Caribbean. Nearly all of the U.S. stone crab harvest comes from Florida, especially the Florida Keys and Southwest Florida. They're a wild-caught seafood, not farmed.

Are stone crabs killed for their claws?

Harvesters remove the claws and return the crab to the water alive, although some crabs do not survive. Florida permits taking both legal-sized claws, but leaving one helps the crab feed while it regrows the missing claw.

When is Florida stone crab season?

Florida Stone Crab season runs from October 15 to May 1.

What do stone crabs taste like?

One of the key reasons stone crab claws are so sought after is their flavor. The meat is often compared to lobster, with a sweet, rich taste.

If you tried this Stone Crab Claws with Mustard Sauce or any other recipe on my blog, please leave a 🌟 star rating and let me know how it goes in the comments. I love hearing from you!

key west stone crabs with mustard sauce and mallet.

Stone Crab Claws with Mustard Sauce Recipe

Felice Kaufman
Sweet, tender stone crab claws served chilled with a creamy homemade mustard sauce. This Florida Keys favorite takes just five minutes to prepare using cooked claws.
27
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prevent your screen from going dark
Prep Time 5 minutes mins
Total Time 5 minutes mins
Course Appetizer, Dinner, Lunch
Cuisine American
Servings 4 servings
Calories 578.8 kcal

Equipment

  • Stone crab cracker or mallet
  • Medium mixing bowl
  • Measuring cups and spoons
  • Spoon or rubber spatula

Ingredients
  

  • 3 pounds steamed stone crab claws

FOR THE MUSTARD SAUCE

  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 2 tablespoons Dijon mustard
  • 2 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce
  • 2 tablespoons lemon juice
  • 2 teaspoons creamy-style horseradish
  • sea salt to taste

Instructions
 

  • Get cooked stone crabs from a reputable market. Remember, quality is more important than size! Keep them cold until ready to serve.
  • Combine all mustard sauce ingredients in a medium-sized bowl with a rubber spatula. Season with salt to taste.
  • Serve cold stone crab claws with lemon wedges, melted butter, and cold mustard sauce.

Notes

Claws: Buy cooked stone crab claws and keep refrigerated until serving. Ask your fishmonger to crack them, or crack gently at home and remove loose shell pieces.
Mustard sauce: Taste before adding salt. For a sweeter sauce, stir in a little sugar to taste.
Serving: Serve chilled with mustard sauce and lemon wedges. Melted butter is optional.

Nutrition

Calories: 578.8kcalCarbohydrates: 2.1gProtein: 41.5gTotal Fat: 43.9gSaturated Fat: 7gCholesterol: 243.5mgSodium: 1764.5mgPotassium: 647.7mgFiber: 0.4gSugar: 1.1g
Tried this recipe? Leave a comment below & tag @cookinginthekeys on social!

More Appetizer Recipes

  • Fried chicken livers topped with chopped parsley and flaky salt, served with lemon and red dipping sauce.
    Pan-Fried Chicken Livers
  • Honey baked ham and cheese sliders on Hawaiian rolls with a honey mustard poppy seed glaze.
    Honey Baked Ham and Cheese Sliders
  • Crispy mahi mahi bite dipped in creamy Yum Yum Sauce with lime wedges.
    Mahi Mahi Bites with Yum Yum Sauce
  • Coconut shrimp served with sweet chili dipping sauce on a white plate.
    Coconut Fried Shrimp

Comments

  1. Suzanne says

    October 24, 2025 at 12:45 pm

    5 stars
    This is the best recipe, thank you!

  2. Jenny Briar says

    January 31, 2025 at 1:58 pm

    5 stars
    Thank you for sharing!

  3. Jerry T says

    December 23, 2024 at 8:56 pm

    5 stars
    My favorite thing to eat! 😊🇺🇸❤️

5 from 27 votes (24 ratings without comment)
Felice Kaufman image

Welcome!

Hi, I’m Felice. I live in the Florida Keys and share easy recipes made with fresh seafood, steak, and seasonal vegetables. My cooking is inspired by island life and made with simple, real food.

More About Felice

Popular Recipes

  • pan cooked snapper fillets with lemon and veggies
    Pan Seared Snapper Fillets
  • pan seared shrimp on a plate with lemon wedge
    Pan-Seared Shrimp
  • sweet creamy coleslaw with cabbage, carrots, peppers, and creamy dressing
    Sweet Coleslaw
  • Seared tuna with dipping sauce.
    Seared Yellowfin Tuna

Fall Recipes

  • Roasted butterball turkey breast with gravy and cranberry sauce.
    Butterball Turkey Breast Roast
  • roasted cinnamon sugar sweet potatoes recipe
    Brown Sugar Cinnamon Sweet Potatoes
  • Small standing rib roast cooked to medium rare with Brussels sprouts and potatoes.
    How To Cook a Small Standing Rib Roast
  • Air fryer sweet potato cubes with browned edges, finished with salt, black pepper, and fresh herbs on a plate.
    Air Fryer Sweet Potato Chunks
See more Fall Recipes →

Footer

↑ back to top

  • About
  • Recipe Index
  • Work With Me
  • Privacy Policy
  • Photo Use Policy
  • Newsletter
  • Contact

Cooking in The Keys is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Copyright © 2026 Cooking in The Keys | All rights reserved

Rate This Recipe

Your vote:




Let us know what you thought of this recipe:

This worked exactly as written, thanks!
My family loved this!
Thank you for sharing!

Or write in your own words:

A rating is required
A name is required
An email is required

Recipe Ratings without Comment

Something went wrong. Please try again.