• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Cooking in The Keys
  • About
  • Recipe Index
  • Subscribe
  • Work With Me
  • Contact
menu icon
go to homepage
  • About
  • Recipe Index
  • Subscribe
  • Work With Me
  • Contact
  • Follow

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • About
    • Recipe Index
    • Subscribe
    • Work With Me
    • Contact
  • Follow

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    Home » Recipes » Shellfish Recipes

    Florida Keys Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce

    Published: Jul 17, 2023 · Modified: Dec 5, 2023 by Felice Kaufman · This post may contain affiliate links · Leave a Comment

    Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

    Florida Keys Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce is the "must-try" food of Key West!

    The tender succulent wild-caught crab claws are caught in Key Largo and Key West and are one of the most delicious foods you'll ever eat!

    Stone crab claws on a plate with mustard sauce and lemons.
    Jump to:
    • How to Eat Stone Crab Claws
    • How Do I Crack Stone Crabs at Home?
    • How Big Are Key Largo Stone Crabs?
    • How to Make Mustard Sauce for Stone Crabs
    • Where Can I Get Stone Crabs Shipped To Me?
    • Are Stone Crabs Expensive?
    • What Size Claws Should I Buy?
    • Nutrition in Stone Crabs
    • FAQ
    • If You Like Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce, Try These Keys Seafood Recipes:
    • "📖 Recipe"

    How to Eat Stone Crab Claws

    Stone crabs are steamed immediately after harvesting.

    They are graded by size: Colossal, Jumbo, Large, and Medium.

    The claws are cracked just before serving in the restaurants. When purchasing stone crabs at the fish store, the fishmonger can neatly crack them for you.

    Just bring them home, refrigerate, and enjoy them within 24 hours.

    Stone crabs with mustard sauce on a board.

    How Do I Crack Stone Crabs at Home?

    The claws are already cooked for you when you buy stone crabs at your fish market.

    You can bring them home uncracked and crack them open with a stone crab cracker, nutcrackers, a stone crab mallet, or a big knife.

    To use a big knife, place the flat side of a chef's knife on the flat side of the claw and press down a few times as if you are smashing a clove of garlic.

    If you're buying fresh stone crabs, place them in a plastic bag and refrigerate them in the back of the fridge. Consume them within 24 hours for maximum flavor.

    stone_crab_cracker_device

    You can pick up a stone crab cracker, a lightweight aluminum device (shown above) when you pick up your stone crabs from your fish market.

    This is an appliance that will crack the crabs with ease. Place the crab in the device, as shown, and lightly press down on the joints. The shells will slip right off.

    How Big Are Key Largo Stone Crabs?

    When harvested from their traps on the ocean floor, the claws are pulled from crabs that measure at least 2 ¾ inches long, and their bodies are thrown back into the warm water to regenerate (it takes 18-24 months to grow back) and maintain their populations.

    How to Make Mustard Sauce for Stone Crabs

    The traditional sauce for stone crabs is a tangy mustard sauce. The sauce is easy to make and goes perfectly with the dreamy stone crab claws.

    Mix all ingredients in a medium-sized bowl:

    • Mayonnaise
    • Dijon mustard
    • Worcestershire sauce
    • Lemon Juice
    • Horseradish
    • Salt

    You can also add a spoonful of sugar. We had stone crabs at a local club a few months ago and the sauce was a little sweeter than usual and it tasted very good.

    key west stone crabs with mustard sauce

    Where Can I Get Stone Crabs Shipped To Me?

    You can purchase stone crab claws with mustard sauce online from The Key Largo Fisheries in Key Largo and the Eaton Street Seafood Market in Key West.

    The crabs will arrive in one day packed on dry ice. Of course, you can also come to the Keys in October for the start of stone crab season and runs through May.

    The succulent meat is a real delicacy. One and a half pounds should generously feed two adults.

    Are Stone Crabs Expensive?

    According to Business Insider, stone crabs are one of the most expensive seafood items you can buy. At $30.00 per pound for medium claws and up to $95.00 for colossal claws, the prices of stone crab claws have been steadily climbing over the years.

    Stone crab claws on a plate with mustard sauce and lemons.

    What Size Claws Should I Buy?

    Whichever size stone crab you choose, they all taste great. Buy the ones you can afford. Your meal can get very expensive if you insist on the Jumbo or Colossal size, claws, and the taste, to me, is not different from Medium to Jumbo.

    Nutrition in Stone Crabs

    Fortunately, Stone Crabs are low-calorie, low-carb, gluten-free, keto, paleo, and Kaufmann diet compliant. They are a great source of copper.

    The mustard sauce is not on the Kaufmann and Paleo diets. Enjoy stone crabs with a squeeze of lemon and melted Kerrygod butter on the side. They're still great!

    Stone crabs are high in Omega-3 fatty acids, copper, and selenium.

    With 31 calories and 6 grams of protein, steamed stone crabs make for a champion's meal.

    With a side of cauliflower rice or a green salad, you have a perfect low-carb meal!

    • Calories: 31
    • Total Fat: .4g
    • Cholesterol: 21.5 mg
    • Sodium: 107 mg
    • Total Carb .3g
    • Sugar: 0
    • Protein: 6.3g

    FAQ

    Are stone crabs from the United States?

    Yes, stone crabs are wild. They are harvested on the east coast of the United States from Connecticut to the Florida Keys.

    Are stone crabs killed for their claws?

    Stone crabs are caught in traps, only one claw is removed, and they are returned to the wild to regrow the claw.

    When is Florida stone crab season?

    Florida Stone Crab season runs from October to May every year.

    What is a good stone crab dip?

    Stone crabs are traditionally served with mustard sauce. Made by combining mayonnaise, Dijon or dried mustard, Worcestershire sauce, lemon, and a little salt, the tangy sauce goes perfectly with the sweet crabs.

    If You Like Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce, Try These Keys Seafood Recipes:

    • Seared Mahimahi with Basil Butter
    • Pan-Fried Yellowtail Snapper
    • Blackened Swordfish
    • Florida Keys Pink Shrimp Salad
    • Roasted Yellowtail Snapper
    • Shrimp Tacos with Pico de Gallo
    • Seared Tripletail with Garlic Butter Sauce
    • Broiled Yellowtail Snapper with Blackening Seasoning
    • Peel-n-Eat Shrimp

    "📖 Recipe"

    key west stone crabs with mustard sauce and mallet.

    Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce

    Felice Kaufman
    Enjoy the sweet taste of Stone Crabs with mustard sauce. Nothing beats the taste of fresh stone crabs, the jewel of the warm coastal water of the Florida Keys. Couple the crab claws with this creamy and tangy mustard sauce for an unbeatable combination of flavors!
    4
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe
    Prep Time 5 minutes mins
    Total Time 5 minutes mins
    Course Appetizer, Dinner, Lunch, Sauces
    Cuisine American
    Servings 4 servings
    Calories 322.7 kcal

    Ingredients
      

    • 3 pounds steamed stone crab claws

    FOR THE MUSTARD SAUCE

    • 1 cup mayonnaise
    • 2 tablespoons Dijon mustard
    • 2 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce
    • 2 tablespoons lemon juice
    • 2 teaspoons creamy style horseradish
    • sea salt to taste

    Instructions
     

    • Get cooked stone crabs from a reputable market. Remember, quality is more important than size!
    • Combine all ingredients in a medium-sized bowl with a rubber spatula. Season with salt to taste.
    • Serve cold stone crabs with lemon wedges, melted butter, and cold mustard sauce.

    Nutrition

    Calories: 322.7kcalCarbohydrates: 5.5gProtein: 40.8gTotal Fat: 14.1gSaturated Fat: 2.4gTrans Fat: 0.1gCholesterol: 229mgSodium: 1759.5mgPotassium: 616.8mgSugar: 2.1gNet Carbohydrates: 5.5g
    Keyword Easy Seafood Appetizers, Easy Seafood Meal Ideas, Mustard Sauce recipe, Stone Crabs, Stone Crabs with Mustard Sauce
    Like this? Mention @cookinginthekeys or tag #cookinginthekeys!

    More Shellfish Recipes

    • What to eat with stone crabs in Key West Florida collage.
      What Goes with Stone Crabs?
    • Shrimp tacos with cabbage, tomatoes, and guacamole.
      Healthy Shrimp Tacos with Pico de Gallo
    • Cold shrimp salad on a bed of lettuce.
      Florida Keys Pink Shrimp Salad with Old Bay Seasoning
    • Peel and eat key west shrimp in a bowl.
      Peel and Eat Shrimp Recipe

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Primary Sidebar

    felice kaufman portrait.

    Hi, I'm Felice!

    Welcome to Cooking in The Keys! I'm Felice, and I'm here to share tasty and healthy gluten-free recipes with you. Let's dive into some delicious, down-home cooking!

    More about me →

    Delicious Fall Recipes

    • Key lime pie with whipped cream.
      Authentic Key Lime Pie Recipe
    • Grouper collar with rice and beans.
      Grilled Grouper Collar
    • Baby Fairytale Eggplants with basil and sour cream dressing.
      Roasted Fairytale Eggplant with Lemon
    • Broiled snapper with lemon on white.
      Broiled Yellowtail Snapper with Blackening Seasoning
    • Carrots salad with basil in white bowl.
      Italian Carrot Salad Recipe
    • Cabbage and tomato soup in white bowl with lemon.
      Cabbage Tomato Soup Recipe
    • Plate of tripletail fish with tiny red potatoes.
      Seared Tripletail with Garlic Butter Sauce
    • Roasted red potatoes in a bowl with gold spoons.
      Roasted Tiny Red Potatoes
    See more Latest Recipes →

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    Cooking in The Keys

    • About
    • Blog
    • Recipes
    • Privacy Policy
    • Photo Use Policy
    • Contact

    Cooking in The Keys is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC associates program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

    Copyright © 2023 Cooking in The Keys | All rights reserved

    stone crab claws